An "Irish" Tradition
posted March 14, 2007
by Pamela Chester, The Savvy Slow Cooker
There is an annual St. Patrick’s Day tradition of making corned beef and cabbage and washing it down with a pint of green beer. But did you ever wonder, where did these traditions come from? Well, the green beer is easily explained—green being the official color of the St Patrick’s Day holiday and the Emerald Isle – along with the marketing of green brew by all the major American beer brands and local Irish pubs at this time of the year.
The corned beef and cabbage is another story. Well, I am loathe to tell you, but what many of us consider as the national dish of Ireland is little more than a myth, since beef was never a major part of the Irish diet. Pork and lamb have always been more popular. In traditional Irish agriculture, cattle were kept for their milk, not the meat. What little meat was consumed was cooked fresh.
A little further research proves that this traditional favorite St Patty’s Day meal is based upon a dish that only began to appear in Irish American households when the Irish emigrated to the United States and Canada, where beef and salt were more affordable. They began to cook beef the same way they would have cooked the “bacon joint,” a cut of pork. That is, by salting or corning it, soaking it, and braising it with cabbage and spices.
A poem written by Frances Shilliday tells us the tale. Here's how it begins:
I just want to put something straight
About what should be on your plate,
If it's corned beef you're makin'
You're sadly mistaken,
That isn't what Irishmen ate.
In modern Ireland, corned beef is considered too plain and modest to serve on the holiday table, although a version of salted pork cooked with cabbage can commonly be found. So you may ask, what other kind of food might one find in Ireland to celebrate St Patrick’s Day? After years of deprivation in the culinary arena (following the potato famine that occurred in the mid 1800s and the mass starvation and exodus of the citizens of Ireland), Irish chefs have developed a cuisine they are proud to show off to the rest of the world.
Recently, several dynamic forces, one of which is Ireland’s economic growth, have come together to renew interest in local food products and to create a new Irish cuisine based on simple ingredients and native specialties such as root vegetables, lamb, venison, and unmatched dairy products. I’ve got a chef friend who married an Irish girl and has emigrated to Ireland; he is now cooking in one of these innovative modern Irish restaurants. He gave me a cookbook from their hometown of Kinsale that features a delicious recipe for Irish lamb stew that I have adapted to the slow cooker below.
However I will always hold a soft spot for good old corned beef, and plan to serve some variation of it each year around St Patty’s Day. The slow cooker is the ideal place to cook corned beef because the slow steady heat will prevent it from drying out and getting tough. You can even brine the brisket of beef yourself in a mixture of water, pickling salt, dry mustard, pickling spice, whole garlic cloves, and pepper; it needs to be submerged in the brine for anywhere from three to five days and then rinsed before cooking.
The contest for my most vivid St Patrick’s Day memory is a tie between seeing the excellent parade and bright green river in Chicago and on another year splashing my arm with boiling hot corned beef and cabbage juices and developing a nasty burn! So my advice would be to be very careful when transferring any large cuts of meat from the hot crockpot to a cutting board. Both of these meals—corned beef and cabbage and Irish lamb stew – are great rounded out with a loaf of Irish soda bread.
So whether you are cooking authentic Irish, or Irish American, Happy St. Patrick’s Day to you!
Irish Lamb Stew Recipe
http://www.cdkitchen.com/
Serves/Makes: 4
Ready in: > 5 hrs
* 1 pound diced lamb
* 4 carrots sliced
* 3 stalks celery, sliced
* 2 parsnips, sliced
* 2 onions, chopped
* 8 small potatoes, quartered
* 4 cups vegetable stock
* 1 tablespoon chopped herbs, such as rosemary and oregano
* 2 tablespoons olive oil
Heat oil in saute pan. Add lamb and herbs and cook for 15 minutes. Transfer to slow cooker.
Saute carrots, celery, parsnips, and onions in olive oil and saute for 10 minutes. Add to lamb in slow cooker with vegetable stock. Cook on low setting for 6-8 hours.
In last half hour of cooking, add potatoes to slow cooker. Ten minutes before serving, mix cornstarch with 1/2 cup water and stir into stew. Stir and cover. Cook on high for 10 minutes and serve.
©2008 CDKitchen, Inc. No reproduction of this article may be made without express permission from CDKitchen, Inc.
printer-friendly version
Visitor Comments
RE: corned beef,no Irishman's dinner comment by big billy goat gruff at 2007-03-16 23:15:56
You are right of course that corned beef was never a tradition in the "ol' sod" nor was any beef dish. Beef was seldom eaten because cows are raised for dairy and normaly not slaughtered untill "there time is near", about two miles this side of the glue factory. Of course by then ther'e as tough as and old shoe which is the reason any beef,corned or other wise is always slow boiled when ever it is cooked. The corning and the boiling and a good set of teeth,hard to find years ago on the isle,helped to make the beef eatable. Now you know the rest of the story.
RE: "corned beef vs. ham" comment by MamieO'Rourke at 2007-11-16 11:35:17
Thank you so much...I have had so many disagreements on this subject. My grandparents, Irish immigrants (who raised pigs), raised us on "ham & cabbage" (heavy on the potatoes and cabbage)...NOT "corned beef". I have always felt that the so called tradition of corned beef was a direct result of the Jewish influence in New York when they got off the boat at Ellis Island.
RE: corned beef comment by big mac at 2008-02-11 00:37:54
a story about the use of corned beef in the usa. when ships returned to port after a long voyage they would discard their leftover cured meat into the harbor where it was 'fished outby starving Irish Immigrants. They ships mates eventually sold their leftovers for a penny or two a lb. and the now infamous boiled dinner was tied to the Irish forever. I can't understand any connection to beer though.
Comment on this article:
Name or Nickname (required):
Subject:
Your comment about this article:
Note: your comment will appear publicly
author bio
Pamela Chester
Specialty: Slow Cooker/Crockpot Cuisine
Education: New York University, French Culinary Institute
Lives: Brooklyn, NY
Weekly Column: The Savvy Slow Cooker
::read full bio::
new article comments
Cheap lunches
rootbeer
question
engine block stovetop
Car Cooking for the Bachelor Sophisticate
Earth Day
Cooking Temps
Kitchen Tools
Hot Crocks
Testing crockpot tempCooking Games
Be the next Starbuck's! Create your own coffee shop. Buy supplies, create the perfect coffee recipe, and try to make a profit!Macaroni and Cheese
Loved by kids and grownups we have traditional mac 'n cheese and some recipes with a new twist.New recipEbox cookbooks
TGI FRIDAYS PECANS CRUSTED CHICKEN SALAD
CROCKPOT TIJUANA PIE
CHOCOLATE CRATER CAKE
CAJUN-STYLE BAKED BEANS
BACON GLAZED GRILLED ONIONS
CAULIFLOWER AND PEA SALAD
ORIENTAL CHICKEN SALAD
TEXAS-STYLE HOT DOG SAUCE
GRILLED STEAKS BALSAMICO
ITALIAN STYLE CHICKEN KABOBS